Property Shield Removes More than 1,100 Fake-Rental Scams in First Year at NNRMLS

This member benefit monitors the internet for stolen listing content, removes fraudulent rental ads, and helps protect consumers from scams.

Key Points

  • Property Shield has removed 1,158 fake rental scams since its introduction in August 2025.
  • This member benefit is included in your NNRMLS subscription.
  • This application monitors the internet and protects against unauthorized use of your listing photos and property details.

RENO, Nev. — You click “publish” on a new listing; your seller is thrilled, and the photos look perfect. But the next morning, your phone buzzes with an anxious text from your client asking why their house is posted for rent on Facebook Marketplace. This nightmare scenario is exactly why Property Shield continuously monitors the internet for unauthorized use of MLS listing content, including photos and property details.  

Online Listing Fraud is a Rapidly Growing Issue Across the Country

Over 12,000 real estate fraud complaints were reported to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center last year, with reported losses exceeding $275 million. According to a 2024 rental fraud survey from Rently, 62% of victims who reported experiencing rental scams lost more than $500. The survey results also indicated that 70% of victims had already paid their security deposit, and over 50% had paid their application fee and the first month’s rent. 

AI has added another layer to the problem, making housing scams even harder to spot. Scammers use AI to copy photos and descriptions from legitimate real estate listings and repost them as fake rental ads with their own contact information. These convincing ads trick renters into sending deposits, application fees, or personal information to someone with no connection to the property.

How Property Shield Protects Your Business 

Property Shield leverages AI as a force for good. The service constantly scans sites like Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, and lesser-known regional websites to find and delete fraudulent ads. The platform cross-references online content with official MLS data to automatically identify unauthorized use of property photos and other listing content.  

When Property Shield detects suspicious activity involving photos or other information from your active listing, the platform alerts you via email, detailing exactly where the stolen listing content appears. When you confirm the fraudulent use, the system goes to work to automatically remove the fake listing ad, protecting consumers from scams while shielding your brand from reputational harm. 

“Adding Property Shield as a member benefit was a major step in addressing the growing issue of rental scams on media platforms like Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, where cybercriminals use photos they’ve stolen from our members’ listings to defraud consumers who are looking for a place to live,” said NNRMLS CEO George Pickard. “This is a national problem that translates directly to our local market, and with Property Shield at work in our marketplace, our members now have an option to take action, respond to the alerts, and protect their clients.”

“Fake-rental scams have a measurable cost to consumers, as the FBI’s statistics have shown,” Pickard said. “They also damage the trust that consumers have in our industry. Consumers are wise to question the veracity of property ads they see on the Internet. There’s an opportunity for REALTORS to educate consumers that the MLS is the source of truth for real estate information. Property Shield is a tool that helps us all do just that.” 

The First Year, By the Numbers

Property Shield has removed 1,158 fake rental scams since it was introduced in August 2025.

Facebook accounted for 80% of fraudulent activity identified by the system, more than all other websites combined. Property Shield typically has a fake listing removed from Facebook Marketplace within an hour of confirmation, and permanently removed if it is reposted within 12 hours. Craigslist followed at nearly 13%, with listings being taken down within 12 hours of confirmation.  

Property Shield recently finalized a partnership with TikTok, which holds a smaller but rapidly climbing incidence of fraudulent listing activity. Miguel Berger, senior vice president of growth at Property Shield, said that removing fraudulent listings on TikTok currently takes five to seven days. 

“But we fully expect that to be permanent video and profile removal within 24 hours once those final details get ironed out,” Berger said. 

Berger said the partnership with TikTok followed an increase in real estate fraud on the platform. He noted that TikTok is especially vulnerable to scams because it has fewer restrictions than other social media platforms.

NNRMLS’s monthly average member response rate for the system’s fraud alerts has risen from 25% in the initial months to a high of 60% in June and July. An integration with Flexmls is currently in beta testing, and further improvement in the member response rate is anticipated once Property Shield is directly integrated into the system.